Toothy's portrait in HTFA 2. It's also used in HTFA 4's character selection screen.
Toothy's portrait in HTFA 3 and 4. Note that he's drawn with regular buckteeth instead of the much bigger and gapped ones.
Toothy's portrait in HTFA 5 onwards.
Toothy's icon in HTFA Land.
Toothy's icon in HTFA Maker.
Toothy in the overworld map in HTFA 3.
Toothy's full-body portrait in HTFA 3. Notice the wrong buckteeth drawn.
Toothy and Petunia on HTFA 3's credits roll.